Differences between revisions 2 and 4 (spanning 2 versions)
Revision 2 as of 2009-03-29 09:18:20
Size: 2088
Editor: jdd
Comment:
Revision 4 as of 2009-03-29 10:36:19
Size: 1883
Editor: jdd
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 6: Line 6:
   * never use spaces in name (this one seems obvious and is already followed). This is specially difficult in the wiki, at it mostly accepts names with blanks. However this lead to numerous problems, so it have to be restricted.
Line 7: Line 9:
* never use spaces in name (this one seems obvious and is already
followed). This is specially difficult in the wiki, at it mostly accepts names with blanks. However this lead to numerous problems, so it have to be restricted.
 * use "-" (minus) to replace spaces. Don't use "_" (underscore), because many browsers already underline the links. This ("-") is less visually attractive but can't be confused with space.
Line 10: Line 11:
* use "-" (minus) to replace spaces. Don't use "_" (underscore),
because many browsers already underline the links. This ("-") is less
visually attractive but can't be confused with space.
 * avoid "+" sign (Linux+...). Special characters makes it difficult to sort the title alphabetically, few people know if "-" is before or after "+", for example.
Line 14: Line 13:
* avoid "+" sign (Linux+...). Special characters makes it difficult to
sort the title alphabetically, few people know if "-" is before or
after "+", for example.
 * use significant word first in the title. "Working-with-flash-disks-HOWTO" is nice, but will be sorted by "w" and nobody will find it. "Disk-Flash-Working-HOWTO" may not be so good english, but most people should find it when searching for disk help.
Line 18: Line 15:
* use significant word first in the title.
"Working-with-flash-disks-HOWTO" is nice, but will be sorted by "w"
and nobody will find it. "Disk-Flash-Working-HOWTO" may not be so good
english, but most people should find it when searching for disk help.
 * capitalize the significant words initial. "Coffe-making-with-emacs" is nice, but "Coffe-Making-Emacs-Linux-HOWTO" is probably better - seems english standard for titles (?).
Line 23: Line 17:
* capitalize the significant words initial. "Coffe-making-with-emacs"
is nice, but "Coffe-Making-Emacs-Linux-HOWTO" is probably better -
seems english standard for titles (?).
 * Place the words "Linux" and "HOWTO" at the end of the title. "Linux-HOWTO-for-speeding-boot" is nice, but hard to find. "Boot-Speeding-Linux-HOWTO" is far better and avoid non significative word ("for").
Line 27: Line 19:
* Place the words "Linux" and "HOWTO" at the end of the title.
"Linux-HOWTO-for-speeding-boot" is nice, but hard to find.
"Boot-Speeding-Linux-HOWTO" is far better and avoid non significative
word ("for").
I'm unsure if we have to keep/add "Linux" and "HOWTO" in the name. It makes names far longer, but if the document is seen outside of the LDP repository it makes it easier to see it's a LDP HOWTO.
Line 32: Line 21:
I'm unsure if we have to keep/add "Linux" and "HOWTO" in the name. It
makes names far longer, but if the document is seen outside of the LDP
repository it makes it easier to see it's a LDP HOWTO.
May be we should '''add''' Linux-HOWTO at the end of any HOWTO that not already have it, and move from start to end for the ones that have Linux or HOWTO at start.
Line 36: Line 23:
May be we should *add* Linux-HOWTO at the end of any HOWTO that not
already have it, and move from start to end for the ones that have
Linux or HOWTO at start.

When changing a HOWTO name, may be we should keep the old name with a
link to the new one?

thanks
jdd
-- jdd for the Linux Documentation Project http://wiki.tldp.org http://www.dodin.net http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1412160445 ______________________ http://lists.tldp.org/
When changing a HOWTO name, may be we should keep the old name with a link to the new one?

The HOWTO names on the LDP collection are pretty unconsistent. May be we should have some naming policy, let alone for new HOWTOs.

Here are some clues (examples are imaginary :-):

  • never use spaces in name (this one seems obvious and is already followed). This is specially difficult in the wiki, at it mostly accepts names with blanks. However this lead to numerous problems, so it have to be restricted.
  • use "-" (minus) to replace spaces. Don't use "_" (underscore), because many browsers already underline the links. This ("-") is less visually attractive but can't be confused with space.
  • avoid "+" sign (Linux+...). Special characters makes it difficult to sort the title alphabetically, few people know if "-" is before or after "+", for example.
  • use significant word first in the title. "Working-with-flash-disks-HOWTO" is nice, but will be sorted by "w" and nobody will find it. "Disk-Flash-Working-HOWTO" may not be so good english, but most people should find it when searching for disk help.
  • capitalize the significant words initial. "Coffe-making-with-emacs" is nice, but "Coffe-Making-Emacs-Linux-HOWTO" is probably better - seems english standard for titles (?).
  • Place the words "Linux" and "HOWTO" at the end of the title. "Linux-HOWTO-for-speeding-boot" is nice, but hard to find. "Boot-Speeding-Linux-HOWTO" is far better and avoid non significative word ("for").

I'm unsure if we have to keep/add "Linux" and "HOWTO" in the name. It makes names far longer, but if the document is seen outside of the LDP repository it makes it easier to see it's a LDP HOWTO.

May be we should add Linux-HOWTO at the end of any HOWTO that not already have it, and move from start to end for the ones that have Linux or HOWTO at start.

When changing a HOWTO name, may be we should keep the old name with a link to the new one?

Naming-a-HOWTO (last edited 2009-03-29 10:36:19 by jdd)